Written 4th October 2025 | Subscribe to our Christmas newsletter
⭐🎅👇⭐👇🎅⭐
Buy 2025 Personalised Christmas Tree Ornaments here
⭐🎅☝️⭐☝️🎅⭐
Hallmark Channel’s festive reality series Finding Mr. Christmas returns for a second season, bringing together ten hopefuls competing for the chance to star in a 2025 Hallmark holiday film. Under the guidance of host Jonathan Bennett, judge Melissa Peterman, and rotating guest judges like Alison Sweeney, Ashley Williams, and Janel Parrish, the men will face weekly acting and holiday-themed challenges to prove they have what it takes to be a Hallmark leading man.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Below is a look at the ten competitors—and what makes each one stand out.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Angel, 38 – Charlotte, North Carolina
A model, actor, and bartender who became a proud U.S. citizen in 2018. Angel has done his homework—he’s studied every challenge from season one to give himself the best chance of sleighing the competition this year.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Craig, 33 – Lake Ronkonkoma, New York
A personal trainer and actor whose love of Christmas runs deep. His favourite holiday memory is getting a puppy named Nala for Christmas as a kid, and he’s not afraid to lean all the way into the festive spirit—elf costume and all.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Davey, 34 – Lake Tahoe, Nevada
This commercial model and actor has worked with brands like Guess and Nike—and even doubled for Chris Hemsworth. Davey brings movie-star looks and easy charm to the competition, with just the right amount of self-deprecating humour.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Drake, 27 – Denver, Colorado
A model and social media manager known for his trademark hair and confident presence. Drake believes being a true Hallmark hero is about chivalry, charisma, and a little “main character energy.”
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Gabriel, 32 – Laramie, Wyoming
A model and proud new dad who recently welcomed his first child, Jori. His close friendship with fellow contestant Davey might just help him tap into the emotional depth needed for those classic Hallmark moments.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Jake, 36 – Lake View, New York
A former NFL player turned personal trainer who’s used to performing under pressure. Though new to acting, Jake brings discipline, determination, and a sweet tooth for sugar cookies to the festive mix.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Logan, 30 – Cincinnati, Ohio
A server and photographer—and self-proclaimed Christmas movie fanatic—who spends cosy nights with his fiancée rewatching A Royal Christmas. His creative side and genuine warmth could make him a fan favourite.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Marcus, 32 – Hamilton, Ohio
A model and actor who started his performing journey after his girlfriend gifted him acting lessons for his birthday. Marcus admits he sometimes skips workouts, but his passion for storytelling is anything but lazy.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Robbie, 35 – New York, New York
An acting teacher who believes the best Hallmark leads balance heart, humour, and authenticity. Recently moving in with his partner, Robbie says he’s ready for the next big role—on screen or off.
Image credit: Hallmark Media
Rustin, 37 – San Diego, California
A musician with a rock-and-roll edge and a heart of gold. Rustin met his wife in a Christmasy small town candy shop, and he’s ready to bring that same magic to the Hallmark stage.
Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 premieres Monday, October 27 on Hallmark Channel.
Leave your comments here:
